Circular Disqualifier: Motes and Beams.

Our Saviour's guide to criticising others:

" Judge not, that you may not be judged, For with what judgment you judge, you shall be judged: and with what measure you mete, it shall be measured to you again. Any why seest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye; and seest not the beam that is in thy own eye? Or how sayest thou to thy brother: Let me cast the mote out of thy eye; and behold a beam is in thy own eye? Thou hypocrite, cast out first the beam in thy own eye, and then shalt thou see to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye."

Now, many times, this verse from the Gospel according to Matthew is quoted to either criticise someone who has made a criticism, or to shield oneself from criticism. Case in point for the former; Thomas Gumbleton, retired bishop, commenting on Pope Benedict XVI's recent speech at Regensburg:

But there's another short passage that Jesus proclaimed, that it seems to me if Pope Benedict had been thinking about this, he would have been much more careful in what he said.

Remember the part when Jesus is talking to the people who are correcting other people. He challenged them, "Look, you can see the speck in somebody else's eye, but you can't see the beam in your own eye!" If you look at others but don't look at yourself. Pope Benedict in speaking about Islam -- yes, at times, there has been those who have used it in a violent way, who spread their message through war, through killing. But you don't have to look very far into the history of the Christian religion to discover that we've done the same thing many, many times.

Now, the Mote/Beam missile can only be used by those who are entirely sure of their unquestionable holiness, or are completely oblivious to the irony of using an argument against criticism to criticise someone. It is a weapon that, once launched, negates the legitimacy of the launcher.

As for Gumbleton, and to bring this in full circle: Remember the part when Jesus is talking to the people who are correcting other people. He challenged them, "Look, you can see the speck in somebody else's eye, but you can't see the beam in your own eye!" If you look at others but don't look at yourself. Thomas Gumbleton in speaking about Pope Benedict -- yes, at times, there has been those who have questioned other's theology, who spread their message through blunt discussion, through unvetted polemic. But you don't have to look very far into the history of american Catholic prelates to discover that we've done the same thing many, many times.